As I’ve shared a few times, Charlotte is doing fabulously at school. Fabulous.

Things, however, are not quite as fabulous on the home-front.

If I get to dwelling on this too long, I will start to berate myself. It’s all my fault that she doesn’t listen. I haven’t enforced consequences enough, I’m not stern enough, I’m a horrible failure, blah blah blech!

Self-flagellation sucks. I hate it. So I don’t dwell for too long on how we got to this place. Instead I remind myself that her development was atypical and we did what we thought was best at the time.

When Charlotte was age 2, and most of age 3, she had almost no true reciprocal communication. Most of her negative behaviors (and there weren’t many) were linked to sensory processing challenges, meaning we don’t believe she could help herself. So we couldn’t bring ourselves to punish her. Instead we focused on creating an environment in which she felt safe. That helped tremendously.

The year she was 4 there was such a tremendous explosion in her communication skills, we were dumbstruck. Sass? A little bit of attitude? No, it wasn’t right, but Oh My Goodness she was communicating spontaneously with us. We were so afraid it might go away, a lot of things were let slide.

And so here we are at age 5 with a girl who communicates mostly perfectly fine. She is handling herself very well in the classroom at school, during swim lessons, during her first-ever dance class this past Monday (where her diagnosis was not disclosed and there was no parent present – yep, we just sent her off into the wilds).

The good news at home is that she is not battling us on much of what used to be cause for meltdowns (e.g. brushing teeth, getting dressed).

However, we have another set of meltdown-inducing, um, challenges.

Example 1
Charlotte accidentally bumps a game off the buffet which lands on the cat’s water bowl and sloshes water all over the floor. I ask her to grab a towel and clean up the water. She runs away.

Example 2
Charlotte is playing with stickers. She dumps out the whole bag of stickers on the floor. I mention several times that she will need to pick all those stickers up when she is done. She finishes playing and runs away, ignoring my demand that she come back and clean up the stickers.

Example 3
Charlotte decides she wants to color. It’s 5 minutes before dinner, or before we need to leave the house. She pushes a chair to the counter and reaches high into the cupboard to get the markers and crayons. I repeatedly tell her that she cannot color right now but that we will do it later. Finally I have to physically block her from getting the markers. She throws herself down on the ground screaming and kicking.

(Those 3 examples all happened today.)

A couple of things are kinda sorta working to bring her back to do the cleaning up. The magical 1-2-3 count coupled with the threat of losing her beloved Belle has brought her back. Threat of consequence however is the only way to get her to do something she doesn’t want to go. Positive reinforcement when she does clean up is doled out, but it hasn’t cleared the way to doing it when asked the first time. Or just doing it period.

To get her to stop having a meltdown over not being allowed to do whatever she wants to do right the minute she wants to do it – I have to use threat of consequence. Which is, again, losing Belle.

I hate threatening consequences. Is there another way? A way that is more positive? I’ve tried setting rules because she likes them, but it doesn’t matter. Plus I can’t anticipate every single scenario. I know that it’s typical of kids at age 5 to not listen to their parents, but I believe this goes beyond what is typical. Especially in her reaction.

Or do all 5 year olds throw themselves on the floor kicking and screaming when told they can’t color? Every time?

What is the best way to get through to her? Do I write a social story about listening to Mommy? About respect?

My ultimate hope here is that she will a) learn to clean up her toys after playing with them; b) learn to accept No as the answer when she simply cannot do what she wants to do the minute she wants to do it.

If you’re on the other side of this, I would love some advice. Or just some good “hang in there, Mom” kinda stuff works too.